Ever grabbed a yogurt from the store, only to take one bite and immediately regret your life choices? Yeah, we’ve all been there. With so many brands sitting on the shelves—some looking super fancy, others dirt cheap—it’s hard to tell which ones are actually worth the spoon. Turns out, not all yogurts are created equal. Some are bland, too sweet, or weirdly watery. So, let’s break down the most popular yogurt brands, from the ones to avoid to the ones you’ll want to stock up on.
Dannon Light & Fit isn’t worth it
You might grab Dannon Light & Fit thinking it’s a safe bet. It’s everywhere, the packaging looks trustworthy, and the name sounds… healthy? But once you taste it, things go downhill. The texture is thin, almost runny. It doesn’t feel like a treat—it feels like something you eat because you have to. And the flavor? It’s fake fruity with a weird aftertaste that lingers way too long.
This brand often shows up at the bottom of rankings like in this Tasting Table review. If you’re after yogurt that actually tastes good and doesn’t feel like a compromise, skip this one. There are better options at the same price or even cheaper. Honestly, it’s more like flavored goop than real yogurt.
Oikos Pro sounds cool but disappoints
With a name like “Pro,” you’d expect Oikos Pro to be top-notch. It’s aimed at people who want high-protein snacks, which sounds great—until you try it. The consistency is thick, sure, but not in a good way. It’s almost chalky, and it doesn’t blend smoothly in your mouth. The fruit flavors also feel artificial, and not in the nostalgic candy way, more like chemical strawberry kind of vibe.
According to Yahoo’s ranking, Oikos Pro lands near the bottom because of this strange combo of bland texture and overly sweet taste. It tries to be the protein hero, but ends up being a forgettable sidekick. Unless you’re desperate for protein and nothing else is around, this one’s an easy pass.
Too Good isn’t as good as it sounds
The name “Too Good” sets some high expectations, right? It’s marketed as low sugar, which might make you think it’s a smarter choice. But once you peel off that lid, things go sideways. It’s incredibly bland. Like, where-did-the-flavor-go bland. You might spend more time stirring and squinting at the cup wondering if it’s gone bad than actually enjoying it.
Lots of folks have noticed it, too. In the Tasting Table list, it lands low because it doesn’t deliver anything memorable. It’s thin and forgettable, with an aftertaste that just doesn’t sit right. If you’re trying to cut back on sugar, there are other yogurts that manage to stay tasty. This one just tastes like someone removed everything fun.
Chobani is decent but a little inconsistent
Chobani is pretty much everywhere—grocery stores, gas stations, you name it. It’s become one of the go-to brands for many people, and for good reason. It has lots of flavors, decent texture, and isn’t crazy expensive. But here’s the thing: not all Chobani flavors are created equal. Some are smooth and creamy, while others are oddly grainy or way too sweet.
In blind taste tests, Chobani usually lands in the middle. It’s a solid everyday option, but not the best. If you find a flavor you like, it can be a regular pick, but it’s hit or miss depending on the batch and flavor. Not terrible, but not worth writing home about either.
Great Value is surprisingly okay
When it comes to store brands, expectations are usually low. But Walmart’s Great Value yogurt isn’t as bad as you might think. Sure, it’s not fancy, and the packaging looks a bit plain, but it gets the job done. The flavor is surprisingly decent, and it has a nice creamy texture for the price. It’s not trying too hard, and sometimes, that’s a good thing.
According to taste testers, it holds its own against bigger names. You won’t be wowed, but you won’t be disappointed either—especially if you’re on a budget. If you’re feeding a family or just want something simple to toss into a lunch bag, this is a solid pick without breaking the bank.
Stop & Shop is a hidden gem
If you live near a Stop & Shop, their in-house brand yogurt might surprise you. It’s not as well-known, so it doesn’t usually get the attention it deserves. But those who’ve tried it often say it has a nice balance between flavor and texture. It’s not too thick, not too sweet, and feels a little more “real” than some of the bigger brands.
This brand ranks higher than you’d expect in this yogurt roundup. It’s proof that sometimes, store brands can punch above their weight. Plus, it tends to be priced lower than the big names, so it’s a win for both taste and your wallet.
Fage has that classic Greek style
Ever tried Greek yogurt that actually feels like it came from Greece? That’s Fage. It’s thick, rich, and doesn’t mess around with unnecessary sugar or artificial junk. It’s one of those yogurts that doesn’t need to add ten flavors to be good. The plain version actually tastes… good. Add your own fruit or honey and it turns into a snack that feels way more expensive than it is.
Fage often ranks at the top in taste tests because it nails the texture and flavor balance. It might cost a little more than the bargain brands, but it’s worth it if you’re into that creamy, traditional feel. You don’t have to be fancy to enjoy it—it just works.
Trader Joe’s yogurt is the top pick
Trader Joe’s fans already know the store is full of unexpected gems, and their Greek yogurt is no exception. It’s super creamy, slightly tangy, and has just the right amount of sweetness if you go for the flavored ones. Plus, the price is fair, and the quality stays consistent. It’s one of those yogurts where even the plain version feels like a treat.
In blind tests, Trader Joe’s came out on top. It’s not overly sweet or artificial-tasting, and it’s great whether you eat it alone, toss it into a smoothie, or use it for cooking. If you’re lucky enough to live near a Trader Joe’s, this is the one to grab off the shelf every time.
Next time you’re staring at the yogurt wall, now you’ll know what’s worth picking up—and what you should quietly back away from. You don’t need to guess or waste money on a bad tub. Stick to the ones that taste good and feel good. Your fridge (and your spoon) will thank you later.
